(Controversial featured projects)
m (Controversial featured projects: fixed capitaliztion)
 
(27 intermediate revisions by 12 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
{{April Fools}}{{redirect|Featured project|the featured project on a profile page|Featured Project (Profile Page)}}
 
{{April Fools}}{{redirect|Featured project|the featured project on a profile page|Featured Project (Profile Page)}}
  
[[File:Featured Projects 2.0.png|thumb|300px|The Featured Projects section shows twenty projects on the [[Front Page|front page]], as the row is scrollable. Clicking the See More button shows more.]]The '''Featured Projects''' section on the Front Page is where [[project]]s featured by the [[Scratch Team]] are displayed. Featured Projects is the highest slot on the Front Page, and the projects that are featured usually reach great popularity.
+
[[File:Featured Projects 2.0.png|thumb|300px|The Featured Projects section shows twenty projects on the [[Front Page|front page]], as the row is scrollable]]The '''Featured Projects''' section on the Front Page is where [[project]]s featured by the [[Scratch Team]] are displayed. Featured Projects is the highest slot on the Front Page, and the projects that are featured usually reach great popularity.
 +
 
 +
Some users have suggested that there be a featured users section as well.<ref>NolanAwesome. (8/5/2014). “Featured users.[title]” [[topic:38198]]</ref>
  
Some users have suggested that there be a featured users section as well.<ref>NolanAwesome. (8/5/2014). “Featured users.[title]” https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/38198/</ref>
 
 
==Why a Project Gets Featured==
 
==Why a Project Gets Featured==
 
[[File:ST reviewing.png|thumb|The Scratch Team process of featuring and [[Project Review Status|reviewing]] a project.]]
 
[[File:ST reviewing.png|thumb|The Scratch Team process of featuring and [[Project Review Status|reviewing]] a project.]]
 
Featured projects are not normally chosen for being an advanced project {{-}} rather, what is looked for are projects that are unique and have an interesting touch.
 
Featured projects are not normally chosen for being an advanced project {{-}} rather, what is looked for are projects that are unique and have an interesting touch.
 +
 +
In rare cases, a featured project is later unfeatured, mostly if the project was featured on accident or turns out to be a blatant [[Project Copying|copy of another project]]. The project would also be taken out if it is unshared.
  
 
==Recommendations==
 
==Recommendations==
Users are allowed to recommend projects to be featured in a [https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/198735/ forum thread] in the [[Scratch Discussion Forums|Scratch Forums]].
+
Users can recommend projects to be featured in a [https://scratch.mit.edu/studios/4228481/ studio] created by the Scratch Team and curated by several [[Scratchers]].
  
The forum thread lists what the Scratch Team is looking for:
+
As stated in both locations, the Scratch Team is looking for:
*Simple projects
+
* Simple projects
*Complex projects
+
* Complex projects
*Projects that show an innovative use of [[Scratch]]
+
* Projects that show an innovative use of [[Scratch]]
*Projects that promote [[collaboration (group)|collaboration]] and [[remix]]ing
+
* Projects that promote [[collaboration (group)|collaboration]] and [[remix]]ing
*Projects that show diversity in the [[Scratch Community]], such as gender, age, culture, country, interests, and so on
+
* Projects that show diversity in the [[Scratch Community]], such as gender, age, culture, country, interests, and so on
*Projects that different kind of people would find enjoyable
+
* Projects that different kind of people would find enjoyable
*Projects that inspire
+
* Projects that inspire
  
 
There are restrictions as well; one can not submit a project if it:
 
There are restrictions as well; one can not submit a project if it:
  
*Was created by you (the most commonly violated condition{{cn}})
+
* Was created by you (the most commonly violated condition<ref>Paddle2See. (4/2/2017) "A project CANNOT be submitted if it… 1. was created by you. This means that you CANNOT submit your project." [[topic:245007]]</ref>)
*Was created by someone who has been on the front page already in the past two months, excluding the [[Newest Projects]] and [[Scratch Design Studio]] sections of the front page
+
* Was created by a family member
*Has received more than 100 loveits already
+
* Was created by someone who has been on the front page already in the past two months, excluding the [[Newest Projects]] and [[Scratch Design Studio]] sections of the front page
*Contains violence
+
* Has received more than 100 love-its already
*Contains language inappropriate for any age
+
* Contains violence
*Is a copy of a commercial game or story; however, it is okay if it was inspired by it
+
* Contains language inappropriate for any age
*Has been on the front page already, excluding Newest Projects or the Scratch Design Studio rows
+
* Is a copy of a commercial game or story; however, it is okay if it was inspired by it
*Does not work well online
+
* Has been on the front page already, excluding Newest Projects or the Scratch Design Studio rows
 +
* Does not work well online
  
The restrictions were changed after a user complained about them.<ref>Paddle2See. (30/4/2015). “Your suggestion has been accepted.  We [changed feature requirements].” https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/981480/</ref>
+
The restrictions were changed after a user complained about them.<ref>Paddle2See. (30/4/2015). “Your suggestion has been accepted.  We [changed feature requirements].” [[post:981480]]</ref>
  
==Controversy==
+
===Controversial Featured Projects===
There were some dispute over the quality of the featured projects.<ref>Zarlog. (7/8/2015). “Quality in featured projects has gone down.” https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/140496/</ref> Most of the featured projects were usually simple. This dispute was set back because Scratch Team are looking for simple projects to feature and complex projects usually get popular on their own.
+
* [https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/72080522/ Interactive Katzenklavier] {{-}} A [[Music Projects|music project]] which involves making cats meow at different pitches by pressing down keys. Shortly after it was featured, it raised tons of controversy about animal cruelty,<ref>Medley7. (10/8/2015). “A lot of people think it represents animal abuse.” [[topic:141400]]</ref> due to the real concept of the [[Wikipedia:Cat piano|katzenklavier]], but later settled down.
===Controversial featured projects===
+
* [https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/164303874/ Animated pride flag] {{-}} A project which involved a simple animation of a rainbow flag meant to promote LGBT rights. It became unsurprisingly controversial, resulting in many homophobic comments and remixes, which were later removed. It even lead to people questioning whether or not the Scratch Team was making political stances on subjects.<ref>-TheBlackParade-. (28/6/2017). “The Scratch Team Should Not Make Political Statements.[title]” [[topic:268245]]</ref> In response to the topic, the Scratch Team released a statement:
*[https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/72080522/ Interactive Katzenklavier] {{-}} A [[Music Projects|music project]] which involves making cats meow at different pitches by pressing down keys. Shortly after it was featured, it raised tons of controversy about animal cruelty<ref>Medley7. (10/8/2015). “A lot of people think it represents animal abuse.” https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/141400/</ref>, due to the real concept of the [[Wikipedia:Cat piano|katzenklavier]], but later settled down.
 
*[https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/164303874/ Animated pride flag] {{-}} A project which involved a simple animation of a rainbow flag meant to promote LGBT rights. It became unsurprisingly controversial, resulting in many homophobic comments and remixes, which were later removed. It even lead to people questioning whether or not the Scratch Team was making political stances on subjects.<ref>-TheBlackParade-. (28/6/2017). “The Scratch Team Should Not Make Political Statements.[title]” https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/268245/</ref> In response to the topic, the Scratch Team released a statement:
 
 
<div style='margin:1em;'></div>
 
<div style='margin:1em;'></div>
{{Quote|We think it’s important to explain why we chose to feature a project supporting Pride Month, and why Scratch Team members sometimes share projects or icons related to LGBTQ+ issues. The Community Guidelines say, “Scratch welcomes people of all ages, races, ethnicities, religions, sexual orientations, and gender identities.” We believe Scratch should be a space for people to express themselves and share what is important to their lives such as race, gender, religion, etc. We feel respectful comments, projects, and studios about LGBTQ+ are appropriate for the Scratch website. When someone shares their identity, or celebrates their friend’s identity, we want to support that. When someone shares something that is against another person’s identity, we see that as unfriendly and unwelcoming. As members of the Scratch community, Scratch Team members create and share projects about topics important to us, and for some of us, that includes sharing LGBTQ-related projects. And we hope this will inspire other Scratchers to create content about topics that are important to their lives.|ceebee, Scratch Team, 6/29/2017<ref>https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/2701530/<!-- this reference does not need to be updated, the name and date and text are in there already --></ref>}}
+
{{quote|We think it’s important to explain why we chose to feature a project supporting Pride Month, and why Scratch Team members sometimes share projects or icons related to LGBTQ+ issues. The Community Guidelines say, “Scratch welcomes people of all ages, races, ethnicities, religions, sexual orientations, and gender identities.” We believe Scratch should be a space for people to express themselves and share what is important to their lives such as race, gender, religion, etc. We feel respectful comments, projects, and studios about LGBTQ+ are appropriate for the Scratch website. When someone shares their identity, or celebrates their friend’s identity, we want to support that. When someone shares something that is against another person’s identity, we see that as unfriendly and unwelcoming. As members of the Scratch community, Scratch Team members create and share projects about topics important to us, and for some of us, that includes sharing LGBTQ-related projects. And we hope this will inspire other Scratchers to create content about topics that are important to their lives.|ceebee, Scratch Team, 6/29/2017<ref>[[post:2701530]]</ref>}}
 +
 
 +
* [https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/168954677/ Snowflakes] {{-}} This is a simple project where you click your mouse and it creates a snowflake. Scratchers have been arguing about whether or not the code was copied from a book on how to scratch. This also led to many people saying that their project was copied and they should get featured.<ref>-BoyBust121-. (8/17/2017) ”Hey, I am sorry for thinking that you copied my project. If i get featured for a game that gets popular on the same day as this comment was posted, I will say I am really sorry for criticizing you Smartkmd. You did not deserve that criticism. You did say you used a coding book. I made a project and found out it was also in a book. I am very sorry." https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/168954677/#comments-80709597</ref>
 +
 
 +
* [https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/188820317/ Superhero Elle!!] {{-}} Superhero Elle!! is a simple project as well where the main goal is to customize the skin color, lip color, and hairstyle of "Superhero Elle". After clicking done the text "Now Elle is ready to fight crime!!" is shown along with Elle sweeping across the screen. The simple and very short gameplay have lead to others calling it low-effort.<ref>-theluigiduck2-. (12/9/2017) ""I spent a long time working on this", you say? I could do something like this in 15 minutes." https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/188820317/#comments-85962930</ref>
  
*[https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/168954677/ Snowflakes] {{-}} This is a simple project where you click your mouse and it creates a snowflake. Scratchers have been arguing about whether or not the code was copied from a book on how to scratch. This also led to many people saying that their project was copied and they should get featured.<ref>https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/168954677/</ref>
+
* [https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/170126832/ 無題 (Untitled)] {{-}} This project functions as a Hex color code picker, using sliders to select a Hex color code. After it was featured, it was discovered to be extremely similar to [https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/166671102/ COLORPICKER].<ref>littlebunny06. (7/18/2018) "Hi, I have realized that the newly featured project: https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/166671102 was (extremely probably) a copy of a not so well known scratch project. The title of the project was called "Untitled" in Japanese and the Instructions and notes and credits were similar to that of a copied project. I somehow managed to find the link of original project and saw that the scripts were all the same. https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/166671102/ and yes... I reported it." https://scratch.mit.edu/users/Paddle2See/#comments-47304136</ref> Many Scratchers called for the project to be unfeatured for being an alleged Project Copy and not crediting the original project.<ref>miaml. (7/18/2018) "This should be Featured not that ripoff " https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/166671102/#comments-97253377</ref>
  
 
==Featured Studios==
 
==Featured Studios==
 
 
{{main|Featured Studios}}
 
{{main|Featured Studios}}
 +
[[File:Featured Studios.png|thumb|300px|The Featured Studios section shows the five most recently featured studios.]]
 +
A Featured Studio is a studio that has been chosen by one of the Scratch Team members. They are shown in a section on the Front Page that displays the five most recently featured studios.
  
[[File:Featured Studios.png|thumb|300px|The Featured Studios section shows the five most recently featured studios.]]
+
Unlike other sections on the front page, The Featured Studio section has no time limit. Scratch Team members add a studio whenever they find an interesting one.{{issue|outdated}}
A Featured Studio is a studio that has been chosen by one of the [[Scratch Team]] members. They are shown in a section on the Front Page that displays the five most recently featured studios.  
 
  
Unlike other sections on the [[Front Page|front page]], The Featured Studio section has no time limit. [[Scratch Team]] members add a studio whenever they find an interesting one.
+
Similarly to suggesting projects to be featured,<ref>https://scratch.mit.edu/studios/4228481/</ref> studios can be suggested to be featured [[topic:277336|here]].
  
 
==Featured Clutters==
 
==Featured Clutters==
 
{{main|Clutter}}
 
{{main|Clutter}}
 
On the [[Clutter]] site, Clutters were featured. These were chosen entirely by an administrator, not suggested by the community.
 
On the [[Clutter]] site, Clutters were featured. These were chosen entirely by an administrator, not suggested by the community.
 +
 +
==See Also==
 +
* [[Front Page]]
 +
* [[Featured Studios]]
 +
* [[Projects Curated by ()]]
 +
* [[Featured Project (Profile Page)]]
 +
* [[How can I get my project featured?]]
  
 
==References==
 
==References==
Line 62: Line 75:
 
[[Category:Front Page]]
 
[[Category:Front Page]]
 
[[Category:Front Page Rows]]
 
[[Category:Front Page Rows]]
 
+
[[nl:Uitgelichte projecten (voorpagina)]]
==See Also==
 
*[[Front Page]]
 
*[[Featured Studios]]
 
*[[Projects Curated by ()]]
 
*[[Featured Project (Profile Page)]]
 
*[[How can I get my project featured?]]
 
[[nl:Uitgelichte_projecten_(voorpagina)]]
 
 
[[ja:注目のプロジェクト]]
 
[[ja:注目のプロジェクト]]
 
[[fr:Scratch Wiki Accueil/le site/projet sélectionné]]
 
[[fr:Scratch Wiki Accueil/le site/projet sélectionné]]

Latest revision as of 21:54, 17 May 2019

"Featured project" redirects here. For the featured project on a profile page, see Featured Project (Profile Page).
The Featured Projects section shows twenty projects on the front page, as the row is scrollable
The Featured Projects section on the Front Page is where projects featured by the Scratch Team are displayed. Featured Projects is the highest slot on the Front Page, and the projects that are featured usually reach great popularity.

Some users have suggested that there be a featured users section as well.[1]

Why a Project Gets Featured

The Scratch Team process of featuring and reviewing a project.

Featured projects are not normally chosen for being an advanced project — rather, what is looked for are projects that are unique and have an interesting touch.

In rare cases, a featured project is later unfeatured, mostly if the project was featured on accident or turns out to be a blatant copy of another project. The project would also be taken out if it is unshared.

Recommendations

Users can recommend projects to be featured in a studio created by the Scratch Team and curated by several Scratchers.

As stated in both locations, the Scratch Team is looking for:

  • Simple projects
  • Complex projects
  • Projects that show an innovative use of Scratch
  • Projects that promote collaboration and remixing
  • Projects that show diversity in the Scratch Community, such as gender, age, culture, country, interests, and so on
  • Projects that different kind of people would find enjoyable
  • Projects that inspire

There are restrictions as well; one can not submit a project if it:

  • Was created by you (the most commonly violated condition[2])
  • Was created by a family member
  • Was created by someone who has been on the front page already in the past two months, excluding the Newest Projects and Scratch Design Studio sections of the front page
  • Has received more than 100 love-its already
  • Contains violence
  • Contains language inappropriate for any age
  • Is a copy of a commercial game or story; however, it is okay if it was inspired by it
  • Has been on the front page already, excluding Newest Projects or the Scratch Design Studio rows
  • Does not work well online

The restrictions were changed after a user complained about them.[3]

Controversial Featured Projects

  • Interactive Katzenklavier — A music project which involves making cats meow at different pitches by pressing down keys. Shortly after it was featured, it raised tons of controversy about animal cruelty,[4] due to the real concept of the katzenklavier, but later settled down.
  • Animated pride flag — A project which involved a simple animation of a rainbow flag meant to promote LGBT rights. It became unsurprisingly controversial, resulting in many homophobic comments and remixes, which were later removed. It even lead to people questioning whether or not the Scratch Team was making political stances on subjects.[5] In response to the topic, the Scratch Team released a statement:
We think it’s important to explain why we chose to feature a project supporting Pride Month, and why Scratch Team members sometimes share projects or icons related to LGBTQ+ issues. The Community Guidelines say, “Scratch welcomes people of all ages, races, ethnicities, religions, sexual orientations, and gender identities.” We believe Scratch should be a space for people to express themselves and share what is important to their lives such as race, gender, religion, etc. We feel respectful comments, projects, and studios about LGBTQ+ are appropriate for the Scratch website. When someone shares their identity, or celebrates their friend’s identity, we want to support that. When someone shares something that is against another person’s identity, we see that as unfriendly and unwelcoming. As members of the Scratch community, Scratch Team members create and share projects about topics important to us, and for some of us, that includes sharing LGBTQ-related projects. And we hope this will inspire other Scratchers to create content about topics that are important to their lives.

– ceebee, Scratch Team, 6/29/2017[6]

  • Snowflakes — This is a simple project where you click your mouse and it creates a snowflake. Scratchers have been arguing about whether or not the code was copied from a book on how to scratch. This also led to many people saying that their project was copied and they should get featured.[7]
  • Superhero Elle!! — Superhero Elle!! is a simple project as well where the main goal is to customize the skin color, lip color, and hairstyle of "Superhero Elle". After clicking done the text "Now Elle is ready to fight crime!!" is shown along with Elle sweeping across the screen. The simple and very short gameplay have lead to others calling it low-effort.[8]
  • 無題 (Untitled) — This project functions as a Hex color code picker, using sliders to select a Hex color code. After it was featured, it was discovered to be extremely similar to COLORPICKER.[9] Many Scratchers called for the project to be unfeatured for being an alleged Project Copy and not crediting the original project.[10]

Featured Studios

Main article: Featured Studios
The Featured Studios section shows the five most recently featured studios.

A Featured Studio is a studio that has been chosen by one of the Scratch Team members. They are shown in a section on the Front Page that displays the five most recently featured studios.

Unlike other sections on the front page, The Featured Studio section has no time limit. Scratch Team members add a studio whenever they find an interesting one.[outdated]

Similarly to suggesting projects to be featured,[11] studios can be suggested to be featured here.

Featured Clutters

Main article: Clutter

On the Clutter site, Clutters were featured. These were chosen entirely by an administrator, not suggested by the community.

See Also

References

  1. NolanAwesome. (8/5/2014). “Featured users.[title]” topic:38198
  2. Paddle2See. (4/2/2017) "A project CANNOT be submitted if it… 1. was created by you. This means that you CANNOT submit your project." topic:245007
  3. Paddle2See. (30/4/2015). “Your suggestion has been accepted. We [changed feature requirements].” post:981480
  4. Medley7. (10/8/2015). “A lot of people think it represents animal abuse.” topic:141400
  5. -TheBlackParade-. (28/6/2017). “The Scratch Team Should Not Make Political Statements.[title]” topic:268245
  6. post:2701530
  7. -BoyBust121-. (8/17/2017) ”Hey, I am sorry for thinking that you copied my project. If i get featured for a game that gets popular on the same day as this comment was posted, I will say I am really sorry for criticizing you Smartkmd. You did not deserve that criticism. You did say you used a coding book. I made a project and found out it was also in a book. I am very sorry." https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/168954677/#comments-80709597
  8. -theluigiduck2-. (12/9/2017) ""I spent a long time working on this", you say? I could do something like this in 15 minutes." https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/188820317/#comments-85962930
  9. littlebunny06. (7/18/2018) "Hi, I have realized that the newly featured project: https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/166671102 was (extremely probably) a copy of a not so well known scratch project. The title of the project was called "Untitled" in Japanese and the Instructions and notes and credits were similar to that of a copied project. I somehow managed to find the link of original project and saw that the scripts were all the same. https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/166671102/ and yes... I reported it." https://scratch.mit.edu/users/Paddle2See/#comments-47304136
  10. miaml. (7/18/2018) "This should be Featured not that ripoff " https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/166671102/#comments-97253377
  11. https://scratch.mit.edu/studios/4228481/